Cheddar Store / Cheddar Sort by We recommend Newest arrivals Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Name: A to Z Name: Z to A Fresh Cheddar, 1lb. Fresh Cheddar, 1lb. $5.50 Buy Now Yellow Medium Cheddar, 1lb. Yellow Medium Cheddar, 1lb. $6.50 Buy Now 1 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. 1 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. $7.00 Buy Now 2 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. 2 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $7.50 Buy Now Yellow 3 Year Aged Cheddar Yellow 3 Year Aged Cheddar $9.00 Buy Now Yellow 4 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb Yellow 4 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb $11.00 Buy Now 5 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. 5 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. $12.00 Buy Now 7 Year Aged Cheddar 7 Year Aged Cheddar $16.50 Buy Now Sold out 8 Year Aged Cheddar 8 Year Aged Cheddar $18.50 Out of stock 10 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. 10 Year Aged Cheddar, 1lb. $22.50 Buy Now 11 Year Aged Cheddar 11 Year Aged Cheddar $25.50 Buy Now Sold out 12 Year Aged Cheddar, 8oz 12 Year Aged Cheddar, 8oz $14.25 Out of stock Sold out 13 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. 13 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. $16.25 Out of stock Sold out 14 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. 14 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. $18.00 Out of stock 16 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. 16 Year Aged Cheddar, 8 oz. $23.00 Buy Now 18 year cheddar! 18 Year Aged Cheddar , 8oz. 18 Year Aged Cheddar , 8oz. $28.00 Buy Now Bacon Cheddar, 1lb. Bacon Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Basil & Garlic Cheddar, 1 Lb. Basil & Garlic Cheddar, 1 Lb. $6.25 Buy Now Beer Cheddar, 1lb. Beer Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Cranberry Cheddar, 1lb. Cranberry Cheddar, 1lb. $7.25 Buy Now Dill and Garlic Cheddar, 1lb. Dill and Garlic Cheddar, 1lb. $6.25 Buy Now Door County Cherry Cheddar, 1lb. Door County Cherry Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now French Onion Cheddar, 1lb. French Onion Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Guacamole Cheddar, 1 Lb. Guacamole Cheddar, 1 Lb. $6.25 Buy Now Garlic Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. Garlic Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. $6.25 Buy Now Garlic Parmesan Cheddar, 1lb. Garlic Parmesan Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Habanero Cheddar, 1lb. Habanero Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Natural Smoked Cheddar, 1 Ib. Natural Smoked Cheddar, 1 Ib. $9.50 Buy Now Horseradish Cheddar, 1lb. Horseradish Cheddar, 1lb. $7.25 Buy Now Jalapeno Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. Jalapeno Pepper Cheddar, 1lb. $6.25 Buy Now Olive Cheddar, 1lb. Olive Cheddar, 1lb. $7.00 Buy Now Pineapple Habanero Cheddar, 1lb. Pineapple Habanero Cheddar, 1lb. $7.25 Buy Now Raspberry Chipotle Cheddar, 1lb. Raspberry Chipotle Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Roasted Garlic Italian Cheddar, 1 lb. Roasted Garlic Italian Cheddar, 1 lb. $7.25 Buy Now Spinach Artichoke Cheddar, 1 lb. Spinach Artichoke Cheddar, 1 lb. $6.75 Buy Now Sweet Thai Chili Cheddar, 1 Lb. Sweet Thai Chili Cheddar, 1 Lb. $6.25 Buy Now Tomato Basil Cheddar, 1lb. Tomato Basil Cheddar, 1lb. $6.25 Buy Now Tuscan Rosemary Garlic Cheddar, 1lb. Tuscan Rosemary Garlic Cheddar, 1lb. $6.75 Buy Now Taco Cheddar, 1 Lb. Taco Cheddar, 1 Lb. $6.25 Buy Now Morel and Leek Cheddar, 1lb. Morel and Leek Cheddar, 1lb. $8.25 Buy Now Cheese - Cheddar, Fire Roasted Bell Pepper Cheese - Cheddar, Fire Roasted Bell Pepper $9.50 Buy Now Maple White Cheddar, 1 pound Maple White Cheddar, 1 pound $8.25 Buy Now Cheese - Cheddar, Bloody Mary Cheese - Cheddar, Bloody Mary $8.25 Buy Now Cheese - Cheddar, Pico De Gallo Cheese - Cheddar, Pico De Gallo $8.25 Buy Now Marble Cheddar Marble Cheddar $5.75 Buy Now Cheese Curds , Fresh, 14oz. Cheese Curds , Fresh, 14oz. $6.00 Buy Now Mix And Match Gift Box Mix And Match Gift Box $25.00 Buy Now Cheese - Blueberry Cheddar Cheese - Blueberry Cheddar $9.25 Buy Now Cheese - 15 Year Aged Cheddar Cheese - 15 Year Aged Cheddar $41.00 Buy Now White 1 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 1 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $7.00 Buy Now White 2 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 2 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $7.50 Buy Now White 3 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 3 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $9.00 Buy Now White 4 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 4 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $11.00 Buy Now White 5 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 5 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $12.00 Buy Now White 6 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. White 6 Year Aged Cheddar, 1 lb. $13.00 Buy Now White Fresh Cheddar, 1 lb. White Fresh Cheddar, 1 lb. $6.00 Buy Now White Medium Cheddar, 1 lb. White Medium Cheddar, 1 lb. $6.50 Buy Now Yellow 6 Year Aged Cheddar Yellow 6 Year Aged Cheddar $13.00 Buy Now